Falnavar's tales shifts again, this time to the years after the defeat of the Corsair crew who brought an end to the Captain.
'He -- The Captain gave me gifts; precious to me. I kept them with me at all times since his death, now, here at my own - I seem to have lost them. Do you have the heart to find them? To find what I have lost? So that I might have them in my death where the water has claimed me and not a tyrant's blade?'
A slip of the tongue? It is unclear, but the mariner's tale continues on.
The beast is defeated, but a mystery is revealed. Return to the mariner and tell him what you discovered.